7 BIG Mistakes Sunday School Teachers Make
You’re a Sunday School teacher. You don’t make mistakes…right Wrong. You may be a seasoned teacher–a literal Sunday School dinosaur– but you’re still human!
We all have stuff to improve.
Honestly, I’ve probably made every single one of these mistakes at some point… possibly in the same morning. So let’s look at the 7 biggest mistakes Sunday School teachers make, and how to correct them.
Hi! I'm Nathan, the founder of BetterBibleTeachers.
And yes, that's me in the video. 🙂
have you ever made any of these? I think I've made ALL of them!
Share this with friends:
Mistake 1. Show Up Unprepared
You grab the teacher’s guide and your Bible. You walk into class.
You smile, trying to fake confidence, and say, “Alright kids, today we’re learning about… uh… uh… Joseph?”
The kids will sniff out your unpreparedness like a dog getting a whiff of the neighbor’s leftover chicken in the garbage can.
And many times, they’ll take it as permission to goof off.
Since you don’t know what’s coming next, there will be little gaps or pauses. Those gaps are perfect for kids’ minds to wander!
So Sunday morning is definitely not the time to read your lesson for the first time.
That’s like trying to cook a meal while reading the recipe out loud for the first time… while your guests are watching.
Instead, read your Sunday School lesson the Sunday BEFORE.
You read that right. Sunday afternoon, after church, sit down and read the lesson for next Sunday.
That gives your brain a whole week to think about it!
While you’re driving. Doing dishes. Standing in line at Target.
You’ll suddenly think, “Oh! That’s a great example!” or “Ohh, I could add this really fun object lesson.”
Then, come Sunday, you’re going to feel extra confident. Prepared. Ready to conquer the world.
Or, at least conquer your classroom.
Mistake 2. Trying to Teach Too Much at Once
Teachers, I get it. The Bible is amazing.
You want kids to understand everything.
The theology. The geography. Maybe even a little Hebrew, just for fun.
But kids don’t need everything in one lesson. They need ONE thing.
One big idea. One truth that sticks. Instead of trying to explain the intricacies of the doctrine of grace, try: “Jesus forgives us when we mess up.”
If they walk out understanding that, you’ve done your job well.
So remember, with elementary kids, simple sticks. Overloaded adult concepts don’t.
Simple. Sticks.
Mistake 3. No Fun Allowed
Some teachers act like fun is the enemy of learning.
As if God is in heaven saying, “Okay kids, stop smiling. Stop laughing! This is serious.”
The truth is: Fun isn’t a distraction. Fun is the funnel!
Think about a funnel. It helps you get liquid into a tiny opening without spilling it everywhere.
Without a funnel, some liquid gets in… but most of it ends up on the counter.
Sunday school works the same way.
Kids will learn something if class isn’t fun. But children will listen and learn a lot more if class is actually...fun!
Games, songs, movement, and silly voices aren’t “extra”. They’re essential!
When kids laugh, their hearts open. And when their hearts open, truth sticks.
So yes, go ahead and make those camel noises during the Bible story!
Get My Favorite Object Lessons (plus what to say!) right here!
No boring object lessons allowed!
In this incredible collection you'll find ideas for demonstrating all sorts of biblical concepts in fascinating ways. From eggs to electricity there are tons of great ideas to choose from.
So download my free Object Lesson resource today and get started explaining God's Word in fascinating ways!
Mistake 4. Playing Favorites
There’s always that one kid.
The one who’s always sweet to you. Always raises his hand.
He even brings you a Christmas gift.
And then there’s…the other kid.
He’s loud, he’s wiggly, he may or may not have licked the whiteboard marker. Probably for attention.
And speaking of attention, it’s easy to give more attention to the “easy” kids.
But Jesus didn’t play favorites. And neither should we.
Every child in your class matters. Even the noisy, disobedient one.
When you treat each kid like they matter, you show them what God is like.
And that’s crucial, because that’s what we’re here for, right? As Sunday School teachers we’re not there just to teach Bible facts.
We’re there to love kids the way God does. I know that’s hard. That’s why I pray this before entering my classroom:
“God, help me to love each child the way you do today. Channel your love for them through me!”
As Sunday School Teachers We Are Not Just There To Teach Facts
Mistake 5. Teaching Kids Like Adults
Have you ever seen those old Victorian-era photos where kids are dressed like tiny adults?
Tiny suits. Serious faces. No joy.
It’s giving: “Kids should be seen and not heard!”
Let’s not bring that energy into Sunday School. Kids aren’t mini adults!
And guess what? You’re not a bad teacher if you let them talk. Or move. Or wiggle. Or dance!
Kids aren’t designed to sit still for 30 minutes and listen to a lecture. They learn by:
- Doing
- Moving
- Talking
- Touching
- Asking questions
- Wiggling!
If you find yourself thinking, “Why won’t they just sit still?!” It might be time to change your strategy, instead of trying to change their behavior.
Try this:
- Use visuals
- Ask questions
- Let them move
- Have “wiggle breaks”
- Do object lessons
- Let them stand up when they hear a certain word in the lesson
Meet kids where they are. You’ll be shocked by how their behavior changes when they get treated like kids!
Treat kids like they are ... kids! (they are GOING TO wiggle)
Mistake 6. Just Telling the Bible Story
Are you an amazing storyteller? Awesome!
But don’t stop there! It’s wonderful for kids to know that Daniel survived the lion’s den.
It’s even better for them to know what that means for their life.
So when you teach the story of David and Goliath, don’t end with, “And then David killed Goliath.”
Ask: “What giants are you facing?
Fear? Being kind to a sibling? Doing the right thing when it’s hard?
When kids connect Bible stories to real life, transformation happens.
Stories inform. But personal application transforms!
Mistake 7. Forgetting Personal Connection
Have you ever taught on autopilot?
You walk in. You teach. You leave.
Like a well-programmed Sunday School robot.
But kids don’t just need lessons and information.
They need connection!
Kids don't just need lessons...they need connection!
So why not…
- Ask about their week
- Notice when they get a haircut
- Celebrate when they can recite a verse
Yes, you're their teacher. You’re their authority.
But you can also be someone who genuinely cares.
Kids may forget the lesson, the craft, even the super-expensive donuts you brought to class once.
But they won’t forget you, when you make the attempt to truly connect with them.
So there you have it...7 Amazing Opportunities
So there you have it, the 7 biggest mistakes Sunday School teachers make.
But…they’re actually 7 opportunities.
7 areas of opportunity that we can all start working on this Sunday.
So let’s:
- Show up prepared
- Teach ONE main concept each class
- Use fun as a funnel!
- Love every kid
- Teach kids like kids!
- Help kids apply Bible stories to their lives
- Connect with kids sincerely
I know this is a lot. And maybe you can’t make all these changes in one Sunday.
But why not pick one thing to work on?
Remember…years from now, your students probably won’t remember all the lessons you taught.
But they will remember how you made them feel. Safe. Seen. Loved. Curious about God. And that’s enough!
